Why does free delivery quietly wipe out margin?

Free delivery is a discount the customer cannot see and you cannot miss. Every order that ships free carries a courier bill that you pay out of the order's margin, so on a small basket the delivery cost can be larger than the profit on the goods.

Most chains switch it on to win conversion, and it does win conversion. The problem is that a flat "free delivery on every order" rule treats a one-item order and a six-item order as the same. A multi-store brand shipping from several locations feels this harder, because the same parcel costs different amounts depending on which store or warehouse sends it and where it lands.

A free delivery threshold fixes this. It says delivery is free only above a basket value, and below that the customer pays a charge or adds an item. Set well, it protects margin and lifts basket size at the same time. Set badly, it either leaks money or pushes shoppers to abandon the cart.

What does a free delivery order actually cost you?

The real cost is the courier charge plus packaging, plus the share of orders that come back. Free delivery is only free for the customer, and you carry all three costs.

Add these up per order and compare them with the gross margin on that order. That comparison, not a competitor's offer, tells you where free delivery stops being affordable.

How do you find the break-even basket value?

Break-even basket value is the order size at which gross margin equals the delivery cost you absorb. Below it you lose money on every free order, above it you start earning.

The formula is short: delivery cost per order divided by your average gross margin percentage. As an illustration only, if an average order costs you Rs 90 to ship and pack and your gross margin on that category is 30 percent, the break-even basket is Rs 300 (90 divided by 0.30). A threshold at Rs 300 means free delivery costs you the entire margin, and you earn nothing. You need a threshold above break-even, with room for returns and discounts.

InputWhere to read itCommon mistake
Delivery cost per orderCourier invoices for the last 60 to 90 days, by zoneUsing the rate card instead of what was billed after weight corrections
Packaging cost per orderPurchase bills for cartons, tape and labelsLeaving it out because it sits in a different expense head
Gross margin per orderOrder value minus landed cost of the items, after discountsUsing list price margin when most orders carry a discount
Return and RTO shareOrders returned or undelivered divided by orders shippedCounting only customer returns and ignoring undelivered parcels

Run this per category, because a footwear basket and a beauty basket have different margins and different parcel weights. One chain-wide number hides the categories that lose money.

How to set a free delivery threshold that protects margin

Set the threshold from your own order data, not from a competitor's banner. The steps below take about an afternoon with a month of order and courier data.

  1. Export the last 60 to 90 days of online orders with basket value, delivery zone, courier charge billed, and final status (delivered, returned, undelivered).
  2. Calculate the average courier plus packaging cost per order for each delivery zone, including the failed parcels in the cost.
  3. Work out gross margin per order after discounts, then find the basket value where margin covers delivery cost with a buffer for returns.
  4. Place the threshold just above your current average order value, so one extra item takes a shopper over the line, rather than at a level most customers cannot reach.
  5. Charge a flat delivery fee below the threshold, and show the gap to free delivery in the cart so the customer sees exactly what to add.
  6. Review the numbers every month: share of orders above the threshold, average basket, and margin on orders just below versus just above it.

Should the threshold be the same for every store and zone?

No. A single national threshold is easy to explain but it ignores that a nearby metro order and a far-zone order cost very different amounts to ship.

Two practical options work for a chain. The first is zone-based thresholds: a lower bar for local deliveries and a higher bar for distant ones. The second is one threshold with a small surcharge for far zones. Which one you use matters less than being consistent and checking it against actual cost.

Which location ships the parcel also changes the cost. If an order can be fulfilled from several stores, the cheapest shipping origin may not be the one with the best stock. We cover that trade-off in how Indian retailers pick which store fulfils an online order, and in handling split orders without losing margin, since a split order means two parcels and two charges against one basket. If delivery costs vary a lot between your own riders and courier partners, the comparison in own delivery fleet or courier aggregator helps you work out which cost to use in the formula.

What happens to GST on a delivery charge?

When you charge a customer for delivery, that charge is generally part of the value of the supply for GST, not a separate free-floating amount. Check the treatment for your case with your tax adviser and the official guidance on cbic-gst.gov.in and the GST portal, because the rate and invoicing treatment depend on how the sale is structured.

The practical point for the threshold is simple. Whatever you charge or waive for delivery should show clearly on the invoice and the order record, so the books match what the customer paid. A waived charge that is not recorded makes margin look better on paper than it is in the bank.

How do you raise basket size without discounting more?

The threshold itself is a basket-building tool: customers just under the line often add one item to reach it. That is cheaper than a percentage discount because the extra item carries its own margin.

Make the gap visible in the cart with a line such as "Add Rs 240 more for free delivery", and suggest items priced near the gap. Our post on increasing average order value in Indian retail stores covers the wider set of tactics. Keep the suggested items in stock at the shipping location, because an add-on that turns into a backorder hurts the order more than the missing delivery fee would have.

Do not copy the largest marketplaces. Their free delivery thresholds are funded by seller fees and scale advantages your chain does not share. Industry bodies such as the Retailers Association of India and sector overviews on ibef.org are useful for context on how online retail is growing, but your own courier bills decide your number.

Which mistakes make a threshold fail?

Most failures come from a threshold set once and never reviewed. Costs, mix and courier rates move, and a number that was right in January can lose money by Diwali.

Commmerce, an Omnichannel Retail Operating System for Indian retailers, keeps orders, stock across stores and shipping in one place, which gives head office a single view of what each order cost to fulfil. The threshold decision itself still comes from your numbers: the formula above works in a spreadsheet today.